This scenario is one that portrays the very end of the bulge expansion. The Germans have no more units to attack so they scraped together as much as they could, but with limited armor any attack would require alot of infantry that the Germans did not have. So from that respect this is historically accurate, but in my play there is not much the Germans could do. They must assault a town that is heavily defended with a mixture of armor units. But without infantry AT weapons the German infantry needs to group and assault. The Americans have good Op fire capabilities. From my old notes the Germans got wiped out just trying to get close to the town. The nine German steps were loss by turn twelve without even getting close to the town. So historically I give it a 5 but game wise a 1. This would also be a good one to try again with infantry AT capabilities.