I didn't play the Germans as well as I should have, but the Americans won easily.

The Americans avoided a city fight and sent troops along the west and the east map edge to attack the soft line of Lehr trucks and collect as many 2 point VPs as possible.

The German anti-tank units were a threat but were easily taken out by an American forward observer and that fat stack of 105s.

While the Americans were moving along the east border, the Germans were spreading their line east and had its OBA rain on the Americans. The US hit the German line just south of the east-west "baggage train" road. Once the Americans broke through the Lehr trucks had to be diverted to enter to the north of the road. The M4, which never broke down, got in range and begin shredding each truck that appeared.

To garner some VPs the Germans detached two platoons to march south and take out the 105s but it was too little, too late.

Even counting all the German controlled town hexes, the US won a huge victory.