The Americans came on the board trying to scout out both strongpoints, and quickly ascertain that both are occupied. Sending a full platoon to 0803, the half platoon waited for reinforcements. The reinforcements come on, and advance on 0509, while the detached platoon raced for 0803. Barely beating the German reinforcements to 0803, all the Americans pile into their respective assault hexes. No op fire from the strongpoints was effective, but the Americans cannot generate enough firepower to actually inflict losses on the strongpoints. The German grens pile into 0803, and both sides take a step loss. The American 1Lt breaks hard, as do one of the grens, but everyone else stands fast. The 1Lt attempts recovery, and deserts. The half platoon decides they are more valuable at 0509 vice certain death in 0803. They survive the free shot untouched, but get gunned down in the open on boxcars. Two step losses against the Americans.

Hex 0509 is an exercise in futility. The Americans have even managed to demoralize the strongpoint, but it keeps recovering. Finally the Germans get to the town. They pile in the full strength gren and HMG, counter assault the Americans, and both sides take a step. That's three against the Americans, so the Germans win. The Americans still try to dislodge the Germans a couple times, but to no avail. Both sides hunker down, the additional Germans come on, and add strength to the assualt by replacing the damaged HMG with grens. The Germans manage to inflict one more loss, and half a platoon flees demoralized. The Americans manage to have a half platoon and a leader in good order in 0509 by scenario end, but due to step losses the Germans still win.

In this scenario the Americans just didn't have the strength to deal with two occupied strongpoints guarding their victory hexes, and extensive German reinforcements. Too much to do with the force available. If the strongpoints had both been empty, the Americans could have captured both hexes, but most likely could not hold them both against significant German reinforcements. A draw seems a possibility, but an American win requires incredible die rolls.