The title of this AAR could have also been Remember The Alamograd but the Mighty Finn sums it up much better. This was going to be the largest scenario I have played besides Desert Rats #38 Alem Hamza: Right Flank and I was going to get to be the defender this time instead of the Attacker. I was actually looking forward to playing Soviets that could match up with the enemy and thought this would be a great battle. Besides a few points that I will get to later, I did enjoy the battle.

SETUP

Setups, especially when playing in a face-to-face game, have always had me agonizing over how best to deploy my troops. I tend to over-think the setup and as I play more, I have become better at it but I still have those agonizing moments before I hit the "Send" key on my setup e-mails. In any event, based on the VC of the scenario, I felt I was left with two choices, either setup a layered defense and wear down the Finns/Germans to get to that breaking point for the Armor, or build a large defense in the center of the board and use the armor to swing back and forth to help should a push come one way or the other. I decided on a defensive "bulwark", setting up firing groups of HMGs and combat-efficient leaders in dug out positions in front of the large town in the center of the map with a wing on either side of mixed INF/HMG units dug into the wheat fields. I placed my 76.2 guns and mortars in town and in the adjacent wheat fields, led by a captain who could call on all to fire at once. The T34/85 platoon and my 3 platoons of SU-76s were arrayed in front of town awaiting the German advance. I hid AT units in the woods to the west and the swamps to the east to attempt to surprise any Armor that would try to skirt the town and I did place a sergeant and INF unit forward to act as spotters.

BATTLE

The Finns and Germans entered the battle and made for the forest in the north, heading towards the first small town with the SGT and INF units. From there, the army split into two groups, A smaller probing force going to the east made up of several officers and 2 companies of INF. three of the four STUG platoons accompanied this force. On the western side of the forest, the remainder of the Finns and the single STUG platoon moved down the western edge of the large forest to the northwest of the bulk of the Soviet force guarding the large town. The SGT and INF unit in the small northern town, were able to escape into the woods and looked to get back to the Soviet lines in order to help in the defense. The Finns pushed on both ends, tying down the eastern flank of the line and putting increasing pressure on the right. I decided to leave my line intact and let my units in the woods along with the SU-76s tie down the approaching Finns. I also had a good compliment of Artillery to assist.

Initially, I was able to hold off the Finnish onslaught, getting fairly accurate OBA to inflict several step losses, but the Finns also had a decent amount of artillery, not to mention a ferocious attack in assaulting units. Combined with leaders who were superior from the get-go, the Finns were able to clear the woods and eliminate almost all the SU-76 units by mid-game. As this battle in the woods raged on, the Finns broke off 3 companies of INF and a few platoons of HMGs with several officers and started moving further south, looking to end-run the Soviet line to collapse the western flank and head for the larger town on the southern-most board. Still, I held my ground on the line as the Finns in the woods regrouped and gathered on the edge in order to prepare for an assault on the town.

Artillery at this point started raining down from both sides and the Finns fought their way through the western wheat fields just to the edge of town. The Finns in the woods continued to take advantage of their longer-ranged weapons, being able to fire their rifles at the Soviets without fear of return shots. As the losses mounted and the Soviets attempting to finally consolidate their position by pulling back the dug-in troops, the Soviet sausage got smaller and smaller until only the town and the surrounding wheat fields were still in Soviet hands. The Finns did send several units on an end run to the southern-most town, but the T34/85 platoon and a company of Soviet troops were able to hold them in check.

After several turns of bitter fighting in and around the central town (renamed the "Alamograd"), the Soviets felt that pressing on would be useless and ran up the white flag.

AFTERMATH

In retrospect, the setup I had was not as bad as this battle appeared, but its execution was flawed. I mentioned earlier that there were several points that I would cover later concerning the battle and I believe that the turning points here were as follows:

1. Mismanaging my armored units - Especially my SU-76 units. I moved them into positions that I thought would work but once again failed to pay attention to the ranges on the German armored guns, allowing long-range, killing shots. I should have kept those units as far as possible from the Armor, using them to harass the infantry units approaching the town. The T34/85 I was able to use more effectively, but as it was only one platoon, I couldn't manoeuver into favorable positions for firing.

2. Remaining immobile far too long - Vince did say that there was nothing wrong with my setup, but the problem was not moving units into better positions while the Finns committed to the attack on the western flank. After mid-game, it seemed a light-bulb went on in my head as I noticed that the small force on the eastern side would not be able to effectively push westward and I could afford to move some of the units there to help in the west and also to move south to help defend that town.

I did enjoy this scenario, despite the outcome. I do believe that the Finns did have the advantage in officers as they had 12 of 16 officers with morale modifiers (3 of them with "2"s), where the Soviets had 6 of 12 (all "1"s) but I don't think that was the deciding factor. It does provide a lot of different options for setup (all of which I agonized over) and a good mix of units and a fairly even OB.