Panzer Grenadier Battles on April 26th:
Afrika Korps #28 - "Meet Me at the Pass" Edelweiss: Expanded #13 - Spring Offensive
Army Group South Ukraine #1 - A Meaningless Day First Axis #20 - End Game in Italy
Army Group South Ukraine #4 - Beyond the Prut Parachutes Over Crete #39 - Corinith
Edelweiss #10 - Spring Offensive Road to Berlin #71 - Horst Wessel's Last Verse
Edelweiss IV #19 - Spring Offensive
No rollover
Author Matt W
Method Solo
Victor Germany
Play Date 2012-09-17
Language English
Scenario AFro020

Sometimes you play a scenario that, due to the dice, just doesn't work. This is one time where that happened. An armor heavy Finnish unit needs to clear a road through the woods of a stubborn German machine gun battalion with AT support. While the AT guns are decent they only have an AT factor equal to the armor on the Finnish AFVs. This means that they should be able to have a reasonable chance of exposing themselves at long range without being immediately hit.

With an intro like that, of course they were immediately hit on the first two shots of the game. This left the attacking Finns without the armor support they needed and the infantry moving up was crushed by the HMGs of the Germans. At turn 6 the Finns had lost 1/4 of their armor and 3/8 of their infantry to no losses for the Germans.

Even without the losses the lack of a morale advantage for the Finns left me scratching my head as to how to accomplish the task for the Finns. The Germans just have to stay close to the road, the Finns have to completely chase them away. With a morale of "8" the Germans aren't going to be running away so they have to be pushed and the Finns don't have overwhelming stregth. As a matter of fact, they are outgunned by a couple of DF factors.

I was not enthralled with the situation at all. The balance seems out of whack and the historical result is indicative of a morale differential being present. I give this one a "2" as the history doesn't seem acheivable with the forces as they are presented.

0 Comments
You must be a registered member and logged-in to post a comment.
Page generated in 0.056 seconds.