Poll: Should a demoralized unit, failing to recover be required to exit an entrenchment assault hex?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes
25.00%
8 25.00%
No
75.00%
24 75.00%
Total 32 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Demoralized unit in assault hex failing to recover while in entrenchment
02-13-2024, 05:03 AM,
#11
RE: Demoralized unit in assault hex failing to recover while in entrenchment
Copied from the PG-HQ Section of Annotated Rules and Charts along with Modern Rules
[font]Regardless of Third or Fourth Edition rules and PG Modern Rules, each section under Morale, subsection Demoralizations, under [/font]Exceptions[font], clearly reference [/font]14.35 (Modern 15.35) [font]which states, well you can read it for yourself.[/font]

[font]If this was not the correct way to play demoralization in entrenchments in an Assault Hex then Why would the game designer make a reference to 14.35 (Modern 15.53) at all at the end of the Exceptions for Fleeing.  This subsection was not part of the Second Edition Rules.[/font]

Third Edition Rules:
14.0 Morale
14.3 Demoralization
[font] [/font]
14.31 Fleeing
EXCEPTION[font]: A demoralized leader or unit in a hex containing an entrenchment is not required to flee, but may do so if desired ([/font]14.35[font]).[/font]
[font] [/font]
14.35
[font]Demoralized units in an assault hex that fail morale must exit the hex, and may move only one hex when doing so ([/font]12.13[font]). On later activations they flee at full movement rate if they fail to recover.[/font]
[font] [/font]
Fourth Edition Rules:
14.0 Morale
14.3 Demoralization
[font] [/font]
14.31 Fleeing
[font]Exception: A demoralized leader or unit in a hex containing an entrenchment is not required to flee, but may do so if desired. See also [/font]14.35[font].[/font]
[font] [/font]
14.35
[font]Demoralized units in an assault hex that fail a morale check must exit the hex, and may move only one hex when doing so ([/font]12.13[font]). On later activations they flee at their full movement rate if they fail to recover.[/font]
[font] [/font]
PG (Modern) Rules
[font] [/font]
15.0 Morale
[font] [/font]
15.31 Fleeing
[font]Exception: A demoralized leader or unit in a hex containing an entrenchment is not required to flee, but may do so if desired. See also 15.35[/font]
[font] [/font]
15.35
[font]Demoralized units in an assault hex that fail morale must exit the hex, and may move only one hex when doing so (12.1.4). On later activations they flee at their full movement rate if they fail to recover.[/font]
Reconquista, PANISTA, OldPueblo And 4 others like this post
“We're Americans, you know what that means? That means our forefathers were kicked out of every decent country in the world… We’re the underdog!”
Reply
05-28-2024, 10:39 PM,
#12
RE: Demoralized unit in assault hex failing to recover while in entrenchment
I voted "yes" because the "must exit and assault hex" is mentioned both in 12.13 and 14.35 and thus brackets 14.31 like a good artillery barrage.  And also, because 14.31 refers to 14.35 to make the point that in an assault hex you MUST flee.
CavDo, treadasaurusrex, Miguelibal And 8 others like this post
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)