Login

campsawyer · 06-12-2012, 12:27 PM,

(06-12-2012, 11:12 AM)Shad Wrote: (link to sign-up thread)

Scenario of the Month 2012 July - Scenario Selection Voting!
Reminder that scenario selection is based on the following principles (in this order):

a scenario that is owned and playable by as large a part of the participants as possible

a scenario that none of the participants have played before

a scenario that has no prior plays in the PG-HQ database

a scenario that has no prior AARs in the PG-HQ database

Requirement 1 - Max Ownership

17 members signed up, collection analysis is as follows:

100% Ownership - Elsenborn Ridge
88% Ownership - Road to Berlin, Eastern Front, Desert Rats, & Afrika Korps

This being the first ever scenario of the month, I'm inclined to select the game which lets everyone who signed-up participate, so we're going with Elsenborn Ridge.

Requirement 2 - New to Everyone

There are 17 Elsenborn Ridge scenarios that have not been played by anyone who signed-up...

Requirement 3 - No plays in PG-HQ

Elsenborn Ridge has 100% play coverage so this requirement is waived.

Requirement 4 - No AARs in PG-HQ

Elsenborn Ridge has 100% AAR coverage so this requirement is also waived.

Results

We still have 17 eligible scenarios, so with a little background data I present them to you for a vote:

#04 - "Second-Hand Lions" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 81 - Maps: 4 - Rating: 3.5

#08 - "Twin Villages: Panzer Graveyard" - Day - Turns: 16 - Counters: 76 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4

#12 - "Twin Villages: Finale" - Day - Turns: 16 - Counters: 56 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4

#13 - "Crossroads: We Fight and Die Here" - Night - Turns: 16 - Counters: 41 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 3

#16 - "Crossroads: Hunting Panthers" - Night - Turns: 20 - Counters: 91 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4.4

#17 - "Crossroads: Panzer Attack" - Day - Turns: 16 - Counters: 106 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4.2

#19 - "Bastard Tanks" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 60 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.86

#25 - "Elsenborn Ridge" - Day - Turns: 20 - Counters: 95 - Maps: 3 - Rating: 3

#26 - "Parker's Crossroads" - Night - Turns: 30 - Counters: 100 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.33

#27 - "Christmas Gift" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 53 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.75

#28 - "Boxing Day" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 66 - Maps: 3 - Rating: 3

#30 - "People's Grenadiers" - Day - Turns: 20 - Counters: 61 - Maps: 4 - Rating: 3

#31 - "The Sad Sack Affair" - Multi - Turns: 24 - Counters: 31 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 2.67

#32 - "Hell on Wheels" - Day - Turns: 36 - Counters: 68 - Maps: 4 - Rating: 4

#33 - "How Green We Are" - Day - Turns: 24 - Counters: 50 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 4

#34 - "Return to Parker's Crossroads" - Night - Turns: 36 - Counters: 97 - Maps: 3 - Rating: 3

#35 - "The Forgotten Battalion" - Day - Turns: 22 - Counters: 71 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.5

Final Thoughts

Please vote above. This poll is open for two weeks. If you have a scenario from the above list you particularly want to play, by all means try and lobby your comrades below!

Let the discussion begin!

All have been played by me so I'm out.

Login
Username:
Password:	Lost Password?
	Remember me

Poll: In July I want to play Elsenborn Ridge number... You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
04 - Second-Hand Lions	5.56%	2	5.56%
08 - Twin Villages: Panzer Graveyard	2.78%	1	2.78%
12 - Twin Villages: Finale	2.78%	1	2.78%
13 - Crossroads: We Fight and Die Here	2.78%	1	2.78%
16 - Crossroads: Hunting Panthers	16.67%	6	16.67%
17 - Crossroads: Panzer Attack	11.11%	4	11.11%
19 - Bastard Tanks	13.89%	5	13.89%
25 - Elsenborn Ridge	2.78%	1	2.78%
26 - Parker's Crossroads	2.78%	1	2.78%
27 - Christmas Gift	8.33%	3	8.33%
28 - Boxing Day	2.78%	1	2.78%
30 - People's Grenadiers	2.78%	1	2.78%
31 - The Sad Sack Affair	2.78%	1	2.78%
32 - Hell on Wheels	5.56%	2	5.56%
33 - How Green We Are	5.56%	2	5.56%
34 - Return to Parker's Crossroads	5.56%	2	5.56%
35 - The Forgotten Battalion	5.56%	2	5.56%
Total		36 vote(s)	100%