1. a scenario that is owned and playable by as large a part of the participants as possible
   
2. a scenario that none of the participants have played before
   
3. a scenario that has no prior plays in the PG-HQ database
   
4. a scenario that has no prior AARs in the PG-HQ database
   

(06-12-2012, 11:12 AM)Shad Wrote: (link to sign-up thread)

Scenario of the Month 2012 July - Scenario Selection Voting!
Reminder that scenario selection is based on the following principles (in this order):

1. a scenario that is owned and playable by as large a part of the participants as possible
   
2. a scenario that none of the participants have played before
   
3. a scenario that has no prior plays in the PG-HQ database
   
4. a scenario that has no prior AARs in the PG-HQ database
   

Requirement 1 - Max Ownership

17 members signed up, collection analysis is as follows:

100% Ownership - Elsenborn Ridge
88% Ownership - Road to Berlin, Eastern Front, Desert Rats, & Afrika Korps

This being the first ever scenario of the month, I'm inclined to select the game which lets everyone who signed-up participate, so we're going with Elsenborn Ridge.

Requirement 2 - New to Everyone

There are 17 Elsenborn Ridge scenarios that have not been played by anyone who signed-up...

Requirement 3 - No plays in PG-HQ

Elsenborn Ridge has 100% play coverage so this requirement is waived.

Requirement 4 - No AARs in PG-HQ

Elsenborn Ridge has 100% AAR coverage so this requirement is also waived.

Results

We still have 17 eligible scenarios, so with a little background data I present them to you for a vote:

#04 - "Second-Hand Lions" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 81 - Maps: 4 - Rating: 3.5

#08 - "Twin Villages: Panzer Graveyard" - Day - Turns: 16 - Counters: 76 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4

#12 - "Twin Villages: Finale" - Day - Turns: 16 - Counters: 56 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4

#13 - "Crossroads: We Fight and Die Here" - Night - Turns: 16 - Counters: 41 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 3

#16 - "Crossroads: Hunting Panthers" - Night - Turns: 20 - Counters: 91 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4.4

#17 - "Crossroads: Panzer Attack" - Day - Turns: 16 - Counters: 106 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4.2

#19 - "Bastard Tanks" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 60 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.86

#25 - "Elsenborn Ridge" - Day - Turns: 20 - Counters: 95 - Maps: 3 - Rating: 3

#26 - "Parker's Crossroads" - Night - Turns: 30 - Counters: 100 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.33

#27 - "Christmas Gift" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 53 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.75

#28 - "Boxing Day" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 66 - Maps: 3 - Rating: 3

#30 - "People's Grenadiers" - Day - Turns: 20 - Counters: 61 - Maps: 4 - Rating: 3

#31 - "The Sad Sack Affair" - Multi - Turns: 24 - Counters: 31 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 2.67

#32 - "Hell on Wheels" - Day - Turns: 36 - Counters: 68 - Maps: 4 - Rating: 4

#33 - "How Green We Are" - Day - Turns: 24 - Counters: 50 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 4

#34 - "Return to Parker's Crossroads" - Night - Turns: 36 - Counters: 97 - Maps: 3 - Rating: 3

#35 - "The Forgotten Battalion" - Day - Turns: 22 - Counters: 71 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.5

Final Thoughts

Please vote above. This poll is open for two weeks. If you have a scenario from the above list you particularly want to play, by all means try and lobby your comrades below!

Let the discussion begin!

(06-12-2012, 11:12 AM)Shad Wrote: (link to sign-up thread)

Scenario of the Month 2012 July - Scenario Selection Voting!
Reminder that scenario selection is based on the following principles (in this order):

1. a scenario that is owned and playable by as large a part of the participants as possible
   
2. a scenario that none of the participants have played before
   
3. a scenario that has no prior plays in the PG-HQ database
   
4. a scenario that has no prior AARs in the PG-HQ database
   

Requirement 1 - Max Ownership

17 members signed up, collection analysis is as follows:

100% Ownership - Elsenborn Ridge
88% Ownership - Road to Berlin, Eastern Front, Desert Rats, & Afrika Korps

This being the first ever scenario of the month, I'm inclined to select the game which lets everyone who signed-up participate, so we're going with Elsenborn Ridge.

Requirement 2 - New to Everyone

There are 17 Elsenborn Ridge scenarios that have not been played by anyone who signed-up...

Requirement 3 - No plays in PG-HQ

Elsenborn Ridge has 100% play coverage so this requirement is waived.

Requirement 4 - No AARs in PG-HQ

Elsenborn Ridge has 100% AAR coverage so this requirement is also waived.

Results

We still have 17 eligible scenarios, so with a little background data I present them to you for a vote:

#04 - "Second-Hand Lions" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 81 - Maps: 4 - Rating: 3.5

#08 - "Twin Villages: Panzer Graveyard" - Day - Turns: 16 - Counters: 76 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4

#12 - "Twin Villages: Finale" - Day - Turns: 16 - Counters: 56 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4

#13 - "Crossroads: We Fight and Die Here" - Night - Turns: 16 - Counters: 41 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 3

#16 - "Crossroads: Hunting Panthers" - Night - Turns: 20 - Counters: 91 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4.4

#17 - "Crossroads: Panzer Attack" - Day - Turns: 16 - Counters: 106 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 4.2

#19 - "Bastard Tanks" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 60 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.86

#25 - "Elsenborn Ridge" - Day - Turns: 20 - Counters: 95 - Maps: 3 - Rating: 3

#26 - "Parker's Crossroads" - Night - Turns: 30 - Counters: 100 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.33

#27 - "Christmas Gift" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 53 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.75

#28 - "Boxing Day" - Day - Turns: 30 - Counters: 66 - Maps: 3 - Rating: 3

#30 - "People's Grenadiers" - Day - Turns: 20 - Counters: 61 - Maps: 4 - Rating: 3

#31 - "The Sad Sack Affair" - Multi - Turns: 24 - Counters: 31 - Maps: 1 - Rating: 2.67

#32 - "Hell on Wheels" - Day - Turns: 36 - Counters: 68 - Maps: 4 - Rating: 4

#33 - "How Green We Are" - Day - Turns: 24 - Counters: 50 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 4

#34 - "Return to Parker's Crossroads" - Night - Turns: 36 - Counters: 97 - Maps: 3 - Rating: 3

#35 - "The Forgotten Battalion" - Day - Turns: 22 - Counters: 71 - Maps: 2 - Rating: 3.5

Final Thoughts

Please vote above. This poll is open for two weeks. If you have a scenario from the above list you particularly want to play, by all means try and lobby your comrades below!

Let the discussion begin!