Smoke

[richvalle]

3rd Ed rules. Smoke... 16.1

16.11 Procedure

For each unit or offboard artillery factor firing smoke, the owning player designates a spotted target hex within
range and rolls two dice. On a result of 8 or less the firing player places a smoke marker in the target hex. On any
other result he doesn't.

If someone has 3 oba factors, can you call in 3 hexes of smoke on the same AS?

[vince hughes]

Rich,

No they can not.

3 x OBA can be used together under 9.3 for COMBINING ARTILLERY. Otherwise, if firing at different hexes they activate seperately.

[larry marak]

Rich, do you mean spreading 3 factors from one  battery, or 3 batteries?  In either case I defer to Vince.

[richvalle]

If you had 3x16 for oba. The way 16.1 reads it sounds like you could call smoke into 3 hexes using all 3x16 factors.


And hi Vince! Nice to see you are still around.

[Matt W]

I'm with Vince on this. To hit three separate hexes with smoke you would need three activations.

[vince hughes]

If you had 3x16 for oba.  The way 16.1 reads it sounds like you could call smoke into 3 hexes using all 3x16 factors.


And hi Vince! Nice to see you are still around.

Rich,

Always willing to answer Q's when available, even if I'm out of the playing PG loop.

[Hugmenot]

Yes, yes Vince I believe you. By the way, can we schedule a Skype game over the Christmas holidays?

[richvalle]

If you had 3x16 for oba.  The way 16.1 reads it sounds like you could call smoke into 3 hexes using all 3x16 factors.


And hi Vince! Nice to see you are still around.

Rich,

Always willing to answer Q's when available, even if I'm out of the playing PG loop.

[quote pid='12719' dateline='1441494050']
Thanks! I was going to make a crack about your opinion being worthless because you don't play any longer.  

I figured it was going to be one per AS but figured I'd check. I'm going to find myself playing a 4.0 game using 3.0 rules. The game allows all OBA to fire smoke. That's going to be different. 
[/quote]

[vince hughes]

If you had 3x16 for oba.  The way 16.1 reads it sounds like you could call smoke into 3 hexes using all 3x16 factors.


And hi Vince! Nice to see you are still around.

Rich,

Always willing to answer Q's when available, even if I'm out of the playing PG loop.

[quote pid='12719' dateline='1441494050']
Thanks! I was going to make a crack about your opinion being worthless because you don't play any longer.  

I figured it was going to be one per AS but figured I'd check. I'm going to find myself playing a 4.0 game using 3.0 rules. The game allows all OBA to fire smoke. That's going to be different. 

[/quote]

LOL - Worthless eh egads!!   Until somebody overhauls my ftf games played record, I'm right there for a long time on the front page of stats ...... Hanging around like a bad smell

[Matt W]

Eau de Hughes...