IoG Play Input Query

[Poor Yorek]

My question; if I play a scenario such as Advance Along the Douve, making at least three appearances in the Airborne line, and record each play in its own supplement, do I get credit for one or three unique plays? From the answer above, I get credit for 3 unique plays of the same scenario. The same scenario! That leads me to ask a counter-question. What makes IoG so special that I shouldn't get credit for 2 unique plays of Bitter Irony, one each under West Wall and IoG? Am I missing something here?

In starting this thread, I never suggested IoG should be unique: as should be clear from reading the thread, I presumed (apparently in error), that previous "repeat scenarios" had been dealt with and that IoG, being new to the list, was the outlier. I simply noted the issue with your recent IoG submission. Surely, though, this issue should be dealt with consistently, however it is adjudicated.

Whether repeat plays gain BPs or add to the play count is the underlying issue: currently, they do not: thus, per current policy, IoG and the others should not (but they do). Were this policy to change, and it was discussed somewhat in another thread recently as I recall, then again, apply whatever is done equally.

My purpose what not to suggest what should be done - that's Shad's call - the matter to which I wanted to draw attention was simply that person A submitting a play in IoG gets "more" (in terms of BPs) than a person submitting the same play in one of the original five supplements (in the case of submitting the first, unique play by virtue of more BPs) or in play count and BPs in the case of a second submission of the same scenario.

PY