4th Edition Rules - comment now or forever shut yer trap!

[Hugmenot]

The Surrender rule needs to be clarified.

Something like Modern PG equivalent would work in my opinion if it was changed to something like the following:

"In some scenarios a force is designated as subject to surrender rules. In that case, during the Marker Removal Phase if one or more demoralized units of a side/nation subject to surrender are in a hex without any other udemoralized combat units, and they are stacked or adjacent to an good order enemy combat unit with a Direct Fire or AT fire strength, roll two dice for each such unit, subtracting the moral modifier of any single leader in the same hex. On a result greater than its current morale, the unit surrenders and is removed from play. If surrender leaves a leader alone in the hex, he also surrenders."

It would be an improvement over the various Surrender rules we currently have.

The important points in my opinion:

• Ony demoralized units can surrender
  
• Demoralized units will not surrender if stacked with a good order or disrupted friendly combat unit.
  
• Demoralized units in an assault hex can surrender to enemy combat units in the assault hex.
  

I am ambivalent about AFVs surrendering to enemy infantry in an adjacent hex but I wanted to keep the above simple. Maybe someone can come up with a better rule.