4th Edition Rules / 3rd Edition Scenarios

[triangular_cube]

.....and that in and of itself might be flaw in the scenarios.

GG

Yes, but we are diverging from the point a lot here.  This is a flaw, in these instances, only when playing with 4th edition terrain rules. When playing with 3rd, the attacker doesn't get to leverage their range superiority to the absolute superiority of 4th edition. So an engagement follows from the scenario. The only engagement that exists in these scenarios as played with 4th rules is that of the defender attacking the attacker. 

In 3rd, AK/DR engagements on open ground are night and day different from engagements on against hills. In 4th they play exactly the same. They are fundamentally different scenarios when you pull out the terrain rules and stamp new ones on.