Counting Battle Scenarios Poll

[goosebrown]

Sorry Matt, I go with none of the above, but maybe with bits of a couple.

First I don't think the battle should count for advancement points. You potentially have 3 points with any given scenario and none for a campaign ribbon.

Neither do I. that is what I was trying to get across in number 3

There should be an award to stick on your page and look at though. Something like recording a scenario play would be best.

(snip)

If the battle game record thingy ever gets off the ground, I suggest we also add mini-campaigns as battles. The Vorontsovo campaign, from PG: The East for example, or the distinct sections from Campaigns & Commanders, like the desert campaigns. Maybe the grouped scenarios like the Twin Villages battles (ElsR 5-8), but that would require creativity on out part.

I agree. The scenarios are scenarios and should be pointed as such. The campaigns, tied scenarios, and battles deserve to be acknowledged, but not in the same way as the scenarios. I do not think they should count as advancement points, that is just for the scenarios themselves. I like the idea of some addition to the campaign ribbon.

For my part, I see the battle game idea as a way to gain notoriety on our profile pages without having to hit the high par of playing a complete game.

Precisely.