AK Scenario 41 Set Up error?

[plloyd1010]

I pulled out the maps from MMP's BCS game, Brazen Chariots.  The Wadi Sidi Belgasem, where this action took place, is about 9 miles SE of Tobruk so it was on the northern portion of the eastern perimeter.  The Aussies attacked out of the perimeter to take pressure off of Operation Brevity vicinity Sollum.  So, the entrance for the Aussies in the scenario should be from the west at Hex 2415.

I would agree that the Wadi Sidi Belgasem is on the eastern side of the perimeter, last on the road to Bardia. Here is a map of the defensive lines.

The XXI Corps (17th, 27th and 102nd divisions) is on the western side, on the Derna road. There are 2 detached companies of Bersagliari down near Halfaya Pass. That seems a little far from Tobruk to be the unit in the scenario.

I guess the question would become if the wadi should be an obstacle or not. Until one of the designers answers, we really won't know.