Aircraft

[Poor Yorek]

I don't really want to win on a die roll, I want to win because good tactics. If I lose, I want it to be because the other guy was better, not luckier, than I.

But doesn't this define PG? Consider that one tactically arranges an assault on the 30-col against a demoralized INF on the 1-col, but the 30-col rolls a '1' which the other sides passes, yet the DEM-INF rolls a '6' which then demoralizes the tank+HMG+INF which assaulted ... likely, no, but not so rare that I wager all of us have encountered it or the like on any number of occasions.

On average the better tactical player should win more often than the weaker one, but the variance in PG is fairly high at least as I've noted in my 55+ plays (not unlike poker).