Best Battle of The Bulge scenario!

[JayTownsend]

For me, of all the PG published Battle of The Bulge scenarios, it is #22: St. Vith: The Fall, from Elsenborn Ridge.

It has everything you could want in a Bulge scenario: Tiger IIs, Rockets, assaults guns, tank destroyers, Sherman tanks, Infantry, anti-tank guns and a snow storm. 

[richvalle]

Well dang, that does sound good. I'll have to make that one of my next battles. Thanks!

[plloyd1010]

I don't know about best. Having recently read No Silent Night, and rather familiar with Bastogne: The First Eight Days, I have become a little interested in 3 of the original scenarios as a sort of battle game. That would be: 28. Marve, 31. Kampfgruppe Maucke, & 32. Champs.

[Poor Yorek]

In looking at my own AAR's/ratings:

WS #5 and #29 earned 5's.
ER #22 that Jay cites earned a "4.5" with the point-five deduction just a personal unease with die-related contingencies.