+- PG-HQ Forums (https://www.pg-hq.com/comms)
+-- Forum: Panzer Grenadier (https://www.pg-hq.com/comms/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: PG-HQ Q&A (https://www.pg-hq.com/comms/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Thread: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? (/showthread.php?tid=327)
[PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - Shad - 10-20-2012
Troublemaker!
I'm working on adding game designers to our Library. I just finished manually loading all the BGG data into my test database... creating designer objects and matching designers to their games.
Then I got a naughty idea... why not compare the average ratings for their games?
According to BGG's data there have actually been 15 different PG designers over the years... many more than I would have been able to name off the top of my head!
Using at least 3 games as the cut-off criteria for designers who have had a large impact on PG, here are the unofficial* rating rankings... more or less:
Avg __ Designer __ Games
3.8 __ McNair __ 11
3.6 __ Perryman __ 16
3.6 __ Murray __ 5
3.3 __ Bennighof __ 43
3.2 __ Stafford __ 3
3.1 __ Knipple __ 12
* - these are quick and rather unfair calculations... McNair, for example, is getting a huge boost from Polish Steel and Siegfried Line which only have 15 total plays and whose average ratings are being weighted evenly against EFDx and its 600+ plays... mind the blood pressure, Vince!
Once I finish working on this little addition I will ensure that the ratings are properly, fairly calculated ... but I couldn't resist throwing out this tidbit for early discussion.
Isn't it interesting what sort of information is just sitting around out there waiting for us to pull together?
RE: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - vince hughes - 10-20-2012
(10-20-2012, 07:23 PM)Shad Wrote: Isn't it interesting what sort of information is just sitting around out there waiting for us to pull together?
Oh, you mean stats ?
RE: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - Shad - 10-20-2012
yesssssssssssssss
RE: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - J6A - 10-23-2012
If you use 3 as the criteria, it takes out Townsend's 4.9 average.
RE: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - Shad - 10-23-2012
(10-23-2012, 11:16 AM)J6A Wrote: If you use 3 as the criteria, it takes out Townsend's 4.9 average.
RE: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - JayTownsend - 10-25-2012
I rank them all excellent!
Walking on ege-shells here, must play it safe, in case I ever do a third design or more.
RE: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - Shad - 10-25-2012
I've set the minimum vote count at 50 in order to be ranked. You've got 12 right now, and it's only gonna get worse for you once I add the on/off switch for designer self-ratings. You should start a new thread called "Why everyone should play Saipan immediately!"
RE: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - Matt W - 10-27-2012
Jay hasn't done that already?
RE: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - Michael Murphy - 10-27-2012
I will be happy to vote as soon as it shows up at my door.
RE: [PG-HQ Dev Blog] Designer Ratings? - Matt W - 10-27-2012
As will I. I took a look at the full set of map boards on the AP site and now I have to clean up the drool...