+- PG-HQ Forums (https://www.pg-hq.com/comms)
+-- Forum: Panzer Grenadier (https://www.pg-hq.com/comms/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Panzer Grenadier Rules (https://www.pg-hq.com/comms/forumdisplay.php?fid=9)
+--- Thread: Rule 4.4 Problem, Bombardment (/showthread.php?tid=1764)
Rule 4.4 Problem, Bombardment - saracv3 - 06-19-2018
Here's the situation-
Two Soviet 8-10 mortars (same hex = 16 strength, direct LOS)! bombard a stack w a 3 strength German infantry, a leader, and 3 Soviet full-strength T26s, all stacked together in an assault battle.
Does the Bombardment follow rule 4.4.; in this case? 4 total units, friendly and enemy, are stacked together? Thus, the player would use one die roll for a result of the whole stack?
RE: Rule 4.4 Problem, Bombardment - Shad - 06-19-2018
No, you calculate for a bombardment attack on the German INF & Leader.
Then you go through the friendly fire procedure for the T-26s.
RE: Rule 4.4 Problem, Bombardment - Hugmenot - 06-19-2018
The fish has it right.
The exact rules to look up are 9.5 Friendly Fire and 9.51 Same Hex,
RE: Rule 4.4 Problem, Bombardment - saracv3 - 06-19-2018
I think actually where I'm becoming confused is the 4th Ed. Bombardment Chart, 2nd column of explanatory column modifiers, where it gives a +1 per 4.4 to 3 or more units in a hex, but not does not allude to friendly or enemy. Thus both sides incur the +1 modifier?
RE: Rule 4.4 Problem, Bombardment - richvalle - 06-19-2018
Oddly, no. Only for each side. So the Soviet's get the +1 but the German's do not. Also the Soviets get a -1 due to friendly fire I believe.
RE: Rule 4.4 Problem, Bombardment - enrique - 06-20-2018
I apply the - 1 friendly fire modifier only for adjacent hexes, not for assault hexes.
RE: Rule 4.4 Problem, Bombardment - richvalle - 06-20-2018
(06-20-2018, 03:20 AM)enrique Wrote: I apply the - 1 friendly fire modifier only for adjacent hexes, not for assault hexes.
I would not be opposed to that though the rules don't say anything about it.
RE: Rule 4.4 Problem, Bombardment - Matt W - 06-22-2018
Note there may be another modifier for a direct line of sight on the friendly fire (in the firer's favor, thus -1)