4th Edition Rules - comment now or forever shut yer trap!

[otto]

I see your point and I agree that it is not needed.
However your description of the WWI assaults prompts a suggestion of a possible small change of IA rules, so sorry if I'm off topic.
If that rules exists and it is not used by players may be there is a small problem with it. If you think that it should be used more frequently then a small change could be made.
Possibly the player who opts for the cold steel rule should get a slightly higher "incentive". May be his units should get a bonus when it comes to check morale after and adverse result in the assault table.
... if you really want to kill those bastards may be your morale is temporarely higher.