4th Edition Rules - comment now or forever shut yer trap!

[Matt W]

"I say keep the rule the same OR if both sides to get it, then AT weapon checks should be a rolled 6 (per unit checking) and not 5,6"

Vince,

I like that idea best. That way the defender with such weapons doesn't have to sit there and say "Don't shoot the Bazooka, Ames, we haven't been activated." I don't mind a reduced chance as long as there is a chance. As you mentioned the column shift penalizes the accompanying infantry who presumably are not shielding the AFV with their bodies.