Designer ranking his own scenarios?

[vince hughes]

Has anybody considered the fact that if say a designer rated here a scenario as a '3' then it would beg the question:

"Why are you rating this a 3 when you had the chance to make it a 4 or 5 yourself" ?

I know for a fact that certain designers here at PG do not wish to play and rate their own scenarios as it is a lose-lose position. Rate a 5 then ....... well .... Billy Big Balls ! There's a surprise !

But on the other hand, rate a 4 or less and then its "WTF are you turning in scenarios of less than brilliant when you KNEW them not be brilliant. Why submit such dross" ?

I see Peter's point.

However, it is still interesting to see the McNair's, Murray's, Perryman's and Knipples play their own games and see what they think of them now via ratings ?