Designer ranking his own scenarios?

[Shad]

I think the absence of designer feedback when the designer is a known member is a real shame. BGG members who object to designers rating games are deluded morons pursuing an impossible goal of ratings purity which is instantly and completely demolished every time someone rates a game simply after looking at the components.

Case in point: Eric Lee Smith should proudly rate The Civil War a 10 because it is a stunning, masterful accomplishment that has stood the test of time. That people would ever object just shows how profoundly stupid humans can be.

Yes mother, I feel passionately about this, can you tell?

Lastly, somewhere Jay's English teachers are turning in their graves because both answers to this poll are questions, as if we respondents didn't entender the Inglés.