Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Direct Fire with range exceeding 12
08-13-2022, 04:20 AM,
#11
RE: Direct Fire with range exceeding 12
No, we're suggesting a soldier in the 150mm IG unit goes to a rooftop and spots for the unit.
goosebrown, Tambu, treadasaurusrex And 2 others like this post
Reply
01-20-2023, 02:01 PM,
#12
RE: Direct Fire with range exceeding 12
The rules (Ed 4) specifically say that indirect fire can be spotted by an active leader, but direct fire has to be self "spotted". Yes?

GG
sagunto, Miguelibal, goosebrown And 3 others like this post
Reply
01-21-2023, 03:29 AM,
#13
RE: Direct Fire with range exceeding 12
That's correct. The firing unit must be able to see the target.
ACav, Reconquista, Tankodactyl And 9 others like this post
Reply
01-21-2023, 12:41 PM,
#14
RE: Direct Fire with range exceeding 12
What does a 150mm IG gun fire?
It's not solid shot---it's HE....
So---sighting to target is an area question...you're not trying to hit That Particular Blade of Grass...You're trying to
get it into a specific area---
So a guy from the 150mmIG battery up in the tower using the +6visibility to guide the Direct Fire (over 15min there would be multiple shots)
makes all the sense in the world for that unit....

To me...
RAW works...
CavDo, Tankodactyl, Grognard Gunny And 1 others like this post
Reply
01-21-2023, 03:41 PM,
#15
RE: Direct Fire with range exceeding 12
Having read what cjsiam said.... I believe the answer must be in allowing the 150mm IG a potting range of 15 from towns also. The idea that the gun(s) tend to fire directly is correct and that a unit spotter can climb up on that roof is also correct.

At least it makes sense to me and does not corrupt the rules.

GG
treadasaurusrex, Tankodactyl, PANISTA And 3 others like this post
Reply
02-20-2023, 04:20 AM,
#16
Photo  RE: Direct Fire with range exceeding 12
You have the same issues with the Sig33B (8-15), the Grille (12-15) and the Bufla (6-15), all are DF with long rangers, granted one is considered a tank (BS), the other self-propelled artillery and the last, depending on the game, either AA or self-propelled artillery.
Tambu, CavDo, cjsiam And 5 others like this post


Attached Files
.pdf   Sig33-Grille-Bufla.pdf (Size: 188.97 KB / Downloads: 14)
"Don't let the dirt and rust hang you up, we like to give the impression that we are out of action badly in need of rest and reorganization"
Reply
02-21-2023, 11:29 AM,
#17
RE: Direct Fire with range exceeding 12
(02-20-2023, 04:20 AM)Juiceman Wrote: You have the same issues with the Sig33B (8-15), the Grille (12-15) and the Bufla (6-15), all are DF with long rangers, granted one is considered a tank (BS), the other self-propelled artillery and the last, depending on the game, either AA or self-propelled artillery.

The Bufla...
...you cannot escape it...

It's either an AFV/or a truck....and it can fire at >12.....

I think it's the Platypus of PG...
PANISTA, Tambu, Tankodactyl And 5 others like this post
Reply
02-22-2023, 04:05 AM,
#18
RE: Direct Fire with range exceeding 12
..... and it all depends on how the weapon was historically used and the sighting capabilities. I believe the pieces/units in question should be noted with a "sic".

GG
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)