|
RE: Map Substitutions
Subjectively, I see no problem with logging such plays, particularly if the map switch is noted in an AAR. After all, plays are logged solo that must contend in some way with hidden units; or invoke house rules and such; or, for that matter, either unknowingly or later recognizing that some set-up, OOB or play rule was violated (I've noted one or two of these instances in my own AARs). Scenarios in BN will be significantly different depending on whether one plays RaW vs. Doug McNair's overlaying 3rd ed. sighting rules (as in King's Officers). I've always tried to note the sighting rule I use in my BN AARs (usually RaW).
Again, only speaking personally, I don't see the play logs here as being an equivalent to FIDE Chess rankings where controlled conditions dictate, in part, viability of a play.
|
