Rethinking Smoke

[Shad]

It WAS worth a try..... and would keep the rules within reason. (I DO tend to agree with you but.... since there seems to be quite a lot of "griping" about some of the rules.....) 

GG

I encourage you to experiment, but do it rationally.

For example, if you think the urban assault modifier is suboptimal, play a dozen or more scenarios with urban assault RAW to fully-understand the current modus operandi over and above any variability due to dice or nation/forces involved.

Then think through your desired adjustment, and play another dozen or more that way and compare the outcomes.

"I tried it once and it was weird" is no basis for establishing a sane set of rules.