[Rules] AT Ditches, Engineers and Fog of War

[SleepyGoblin]

Hugmenot,  I believe I am on the same page as you.  The sniper explanation is not impossible, but the Tiger not shooting at the Sherman brings home the real problem.  We are not talking about a single tank where a mechanical malfunction could save the Shermans' bacon.  It is a platoon of tanks, and the Shermans would require an act of god not be fired at.  Still, I prefer the unpredictability the rule bring to the game. 

The problem with creating a special rule for AT Ditches is how many other situations are there where an exception may be in order, and at the end of the day will the rule become to cumbersome to use?