I rated this as a 1, the only scenario I have done so for. As written, the scenario is completely broken. The Americans' only chance of winning is for the Germans to only onboard 7 units through their reinforcement rolls. Americans set up within 3 hexes of the town and cannot move unless they spot a German unit. The Germans enter on the east edge... likely on the southern side of the board. They merely have to walk through the woods on board 10 and exit the west edge. Americans cannot see them, so they can never win. Game over.