This scenerio requires the German's to clear and hold a town and exit nine units off the west edge while avoiding eight step loss. The Germans managed to eliminate the US garrision by turn 11. They had three turns before the US reinforcements arrived so the spent that time exiting the nine units and organizing their position in the board's town hexes. This is where the twist occurs. Now the Germans have to defend against assault. Up until now this has been the US's strategy. The US picked an end town hex and poured troops and tanks into it. As the turns passes the Germans continued to feed fresh troops into the hex. The US never managed to clear a town hex, but did manage to eliminate eight German steps. The scenario was pretty static for my tastes, so I gave it a 2.