As other players said this scenario was heavy unbalanced in favor of the Germans, we decided to change some things : the French had 2 hidden AT guns, and their reinforcements entered on the turn scheduled. This gives the German a more interesting challenge, I think.

Anyway, my opponent was too shy and too slow. Instead of rushing to the village before the french reinforcements arrive, he moved slowly and stayed blocked on the advanced and isolated town hexes north. Direct fire and assault wasn't effective at all, and we were asking us how to break & destroy enemy units ? This is something we still need to learn !

I really think that with this errata, the scenario is more playable for the French, and this why I gave him a 3. Maybe another opinion ?