Tried replaying this one to see how different it would turn out. Americans set up on 40m hills on eastern board and won the turn one initiative but passed and let the Germans advance east on the road. The M4/76's then set up flanking shots on the lead three German platoons of Hetzers and the PzIV. The US won the initiative for turn two and were able to eliminate the two Hetzer platoons. The Germans then eliminated an M4/76 platoon. By virtue of eliminating the two German platoons, the Americans gained the initiative advantage and used it to eliminate the STGs. In the end the PzIV platoon was alone and moved east to take on the M4's, but the Shermans rolled well on consecutive attacks to eliminate the final German unit. This scenario can be won by either side and can be heavily dependent on who gains the initiative in the first few turns.